Yes, it’s good. Very good, even. I can report that The Dark Knight Rises manages to avoid
the fates of X-Men 3: The Last Stand
and Spider-Man 3—two superhero movies
that followed highly successful, almost universally beloved predecessors and failed
miserably to live up to them, ending their respective trilogies with thoroughly
disappointing and resounding thuds.
But it’s far from
perfect, which keeps it just out of range of being a truly great film. Of the three Batman movies directed by Christopher
Nolan, I still prefer 2005’s Batman
Begins the most, though 2008’s The
Dark Knight comes very, very close. The
Dark Knight Rises is maybe a notch below.
It’s not bad at
all—far from it, in fact. It’s just not quite as strong as the previous two.
It’s certainly the messiest. I don’t know whether it’s due to sloppy writing or
carelessness in the editing stage, but there are more than a few moments that
left me scratching my head, trying desperately to connect the dots. I found
myself wondering, for example, how certain characters knew of one another when,
from all indications, they wouldn’t (or couldn’t). Other characters managed to
escape from a particularly dire situation and suddenly reappeared in full
force, with, as far as I could tell, no explanation given. And a few other
characters managed to figure out a very closely guarded secret, and I’m really
not sure how. (Maybe—hopefully—this stuff will become clearer with repeated
viewings.)
The plot itself is
straightforward enough. It’s eight years after the events of The Dark Knight. The Batman has not been
seen in public since. Bruce Wayne (Christian Bale) is now a recluse. Having
sustained multiple injuries during his time as a masked crimefighter, he has a pronounced
limp and walks with a cane. He never ventures out of his home, the sprawling rebuilt
Wayne Manor, and speaks to no one but his ever-loyal butler, Alfred Pennyworth
(Michael Caine). Bruce’s company is failing, his wealth is dwindling, and he
resists overtures of help from beautiful businesswoman Miranda Tate (Marion
Cotillard). He is still reeling emotionally and physically from the events of
eight years ago. Meanwhile, a super-strong masked terrorist called Bane (Tom
Hardy) arrives in Gotham City and, with his team of loyal followers, sets up
shop beneath the streets. From there, he launches a grand scheme that will
systematically generate fear, class warfare, murder, and widespread destruction
throughout the city. This prompts Bruce to once again take on the role of the
Batman, who reestablishes his alliances with Gotham Police Commissioner James
Gordon (Gary Oldman) and Wayne Enterprises technical wizard Lucius Fox (Morgan
Freeman). And there are some new players on the scene: maverick police officer
John Blake (Joseph Gordon-Levitt) and Selina Kyle (Anne Hathaway), a gorgeous
burglar and con artist. Will they help the caped crusader or contribute to his
final downfall? And what is Bane really after, anyway?
The Dark Knight Rises combines
elements of several major Batman storylines from the last 25-plus years,
including “Knightfall” (the introduction of Bane and his stunning triumph over
Batman), “No Man’s Land” (Gotham City is cut off from the rest of the United
States and descends into chaos), and the landmark, bona fide classic The Dark Knight Returns (an older Batman
comes out of retirement).
But it’s also very
much an organic extension of Batman
Begins and The Dark Knight,
blending the sensibilities of both of those films and interweaving and
connecting some of their individual elements within the context of a new story.
As a sequel, as the concluding chapter of a saga, and as a movie in its own
right, it’s very effective. The stakes are high and the damage done is
palpable. During a sequence showing the vast devastation caused by Bane across
Gotham City, one can’t help but remember what downtown Manhattan looked like on
9/11/2001. And Batman is brought to his
knees in a manner that I don’t think has ever been seen before in live action.
There are plot twists
I didn’t see coming (and one or two that I did), and several genuine “Oh,
$#@%!” moments.
But, as realistic a
feel as Nolan has aimed for in these movies, there’s also some stuff that really
stretches credibility. Without giving too much away, Bane sets out to destroy
the reputation of one of the film’s protagonists, bringing to light a dark
secret from the past. But after the brutal atrocities that Bane commits in
public upon making his presence known in Gotham, I find it very hard to accept
that anyone—particularly good, decent, law-abiding citizens—would believe anything
he has to say.
Then again, maybe they
didn’t fully understand what he was saying. I estimate that I missed a good 10
percent of Bane’s dialogue, as it was muffled and electronically processed to
account for his unique face mask. Some critics have compared the effect to
Darth Vader, but that’s not an accurate assessment—I always understood every
word that Darth Vader ever said.
The problem is not
limited to Bane, though. There are moments when the music and the sound effects
drown out the dialogue. I’m not sure whether it’s the film’s sound mix or the
acoustics in the theater I was in, but there were moments where I wished I
could have turned on the subtitles.
But there was a lot
that I liked. I nodded approvingly at Batman’s firm insistence on “no guns”
(staggeringly ironic given what happened in Aurora, Colorado). And there was at
least one major dramatic payoff that I had been hoping for since Batman Begins—though it didn’t turn out
quite the way I thought it would.
The cast is fantastic,
from top to bottom. There’s not one weak link in the chain.
Christian Bale does
some of his very best work as Bruce Wayne and Batman in this film. And while
there’s not a lot of Batman here, the stuff with him is pretty great.
Gary Oldman is, once
again, simply wonderful as Commissioner Gordon. No more need be said.
Michael Caine has less
screen time as Alfred this time around, but he has some terrific moments and
there’s a point where your heart really goes out to him.
Morgan Freeman also
has a somewhat reduced role, but it’s nice to see him again as Lucius. His
scenes with Bale are always a pleasure to watch.
Joseph Gordon-Levitt,
who thoroughly impressed me in the wonderful (500) Days of Summer, practically steals the film.
Marion Cotillard is a
welcome addition to the series. Oddly enough, she sort of looks like a melding
of Katie Holmes and Maggie Gyllenhaal, both of whom played Rachel Dawes, Bruce
Wayne’s one true love, in the previous films. She’s exotic, enigmatic, and very
effective.
Anne Hathaway is downright
fantastic, and not just because of the way she looks in the updated Catwoman
outfit. She’s a dynamo, turning in one of the film’s best—and certainly most
enjoyable—performances, showing different facets to her character and lighting
up the screen whenever she’s on it. For my money, she blows away any other
actress who’s ever played Catwoman, with the sole exception of Julie Newmar. (True,
she’s never actually called Catwoman
in the film, but Harvey Dent was never referred to as Two-Face after he got
burned in The Dark Knight either.)
As Bane, Tom Hardy definitely
has the toughest challenge. Not only does he have to perform throughout the
entire movie wearing a mask that covers most of his face, he’s also in the
unenviable position of following in the footsteps of the late Heath Ledger, who
made an indelible mark as the Joker. Declaring that Hardy lacks Ledger’s
charisma, as a number of critics have done, is silly, pointless, and unfair.
Bane and the Joker are two very different characters, requiring completely
different approaches. Hardy is a good actor and he’s fine in the role. Now, if
you want to criticize the choice of Bane as the main villain for this movie,
that’s another story—and I wouldn’t necessarily disagree. (He certainly wouldn’t
have been my pick, as he’s never been a favorite of mine.)
With regard to the
ending, which became a hot topic when David Letterman supposedly spilled the
beans about it on his show before the movie came out… all I’ll say is, I
approve.
I have to admit, The Dark Knight Rises isn’t the movie
that I had in my head after I saw The
Dark Knight four years ago. It doesn’t go in the direction I thought it
would and it’s not the wrap-up to the series that I was expecting—mainly
because I wasn’t expecting (or needing) a “wrap-up” at all. Aside from
Christopher Nolan wanting his version of Batman to be untouched by anyone else
(and he gained enough clout that Warner Brothers acceded to his wish), there’s
really no reason why this particular run of films could not have continued
indefinitely with other directors, writers, and, if necessary, lead actors. James
Bond lived on within the same cinematic continuity despite multiple actors
playing him. Yes, they pretty much tried to do the same thing with the original
Batman series begun by Tim Burton—Val Kilmer and George Clooney were, for all
intents and purposes, playing the same Batman as Michael Keaton—but those films
sucked. Ah well. What’s done is done.
Another reboot is forthcoming and we can only hope it matches—or even
exceeds—what Nolan has achieved with his trilogy.
© All
text copyright Glenn Greenberg, 2012.
Good review.
ReplyDeleteGreat review!
ReplyDeleteI agree with you that this was not the best movie in the trilogy, but still was an fitting end to the trilogy. Chris Bale was at his best and Anne was great as Selina as well.
Check out my review .
Cheers!
I think I liked it a little less than you, but it seems we made many of the same points.
ReplyDeletefound this list online...accurate?
ReplyDeletehttp://www.vulture.com/2012/07/which-comics-to-read-before-dark-knight-rises.html
Nick--
ReplyDeleteMore or less.
I haven't seen the film and I'm not sure if I even want to, but kudos on your usual spoiler-free review! I've seen other bloggers hint at a few things, and you managed to avoid that completely!
ReplyDeleteEnjoyed the movie thoroughly, but I agree it's the weakest of the three films. Anne Hathaway impressed me... didn't see that coming. Great review!
ReplyDeleteGreat review, Glenn! I have not seen this movie yet, but I am planning to soon. One nitpick in your review: you say that Harvey Dent is never referred to as "Two-Face" in The Dark Knight, but I think you're forgetting the scene when Commissioner Gordon visits Harvey in the hospital. Harvey actually insists that Gordon call him "Two-Face", which was a nickname given to him years before the face-burning incident. (Much earlier in the movie, Harvey actually makes reference to having an old nickname, but that nickname is not revealed until the hospital scene.)
ReplyDelete
ReplyDeleteI aspire to be one of this blogger.Nice i liked the collection
Good working i like it Thank you so much for helping me out
The Batman (2021)